Smartly.io vs Pencil
Which is better in 2025? An honest breakdown.
Expert's Verdict
Smartly.io wins overall with a 4.2/5 rating vs Pencil's 4/5. But the right choice depends on your specific situation.
Choose Smartly.io if:
- ✓ enterprise marketing teams
- ✓ large ecommerce brands
- ✓ media agencies
Choose Pencil if:
- ✓ DTC brands
- ✓ ecommerce performance teams
- ✓ agencies
Feature Comparison
| Feature | Smartly.io | Pencil |
|---|---|---|
| Rating | ⭐ 4.2/5 | ⭐ 4/5 |
| Pricing | paid | paid |
| Free Tier | ✗ No | ✗ No |
| Best For | enterprise marketing teams, large ecommerce brands | DTC brands, ecommerce performance teams |
| Avoid If | startups | B2B marketers |
| Top Use Case | social-ad-automation | video-ads |
What is Smartly.io?
Smartly.io is an enterprise social advertising platform that automates campaign management, creative production, and optimization across Meta, TikTok, Pinterest, and Snapchat. The AI automates budget allocation, bid adjustments, and audience targeting. Dynamic creative optimization (DCO) generates personalized ad variants at scale — different products shown to different audiences automatically. Pricing is enterprise-negotiated, typically six figures annually.
What is Pencil?
Pencil uses AI to generate video and static ad creatives for DTC and ecommerce brands, with performance predictions based on what's worked across its platform's ad data. You input brand assets, product images, and messaging, and it generates ad variations with scripts, visuals, and hooks. The video ad generation is a standout feature — most competitors only do static images. Connects to Meta and TikTok ad accounts for performance data.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Smartly.io better than Pencil?
Smartly.io scores higher overall (4.2/5 vs 4/5). Enterprise-grade social ad automation. If you're spending $500k+ per month on social ads, this is the infrastructure you need. Otherwise, it's overkill.
What is the main difference between Smartly.io and Pencil?
Smartly.io is designed for enterprise marketing teams and large ecommerce brands, while Pencil excels for DTC brands and ecommerce performance teams.
Which is cheaper — Smartly.io or Pencil?
Smartly.io is paid. Pencil is paid.
Want the Full AI Tools Breakdown?
Join 80,000+ entrepreneurs learning how to pick and use AI tools effectively.
Join Free Community →